Why Managers Fail When Promoted Without Leadership Skills
Promoting top performers often fails for managers. Discover why and learn leadership strategies that drive real team results in this episode.
Why does promoting your best doer to manager often fail and what can you do differently?
Explore the topics
Also on Spotify and Apple Podcasts.
What this episode covers
Many good managers fail when promoted because leadership demands a different set of skills focused on long-term vision rather than immediate task completion. In this episode, Jimmy Burroughes and Paul Teasdale explore the gap between management and leadership, highlighting common challenges organisations face in developing leadership capabilities. They discuss how practical tools, mentorship, and peer learning environments can support managers in becoming effective leaders. The episode also addresses the risks of burnout and the importance of measuring the impact of leadership training. This conversation provides actionable insights for those responsible for growing leadership talent within their teams.
Who this is for: General managers and senior operators who oversee teams and want to understand why some managers struggle after promotion and how to improve leadership capability.
Key takeaways
- Good managers often struggle when promoted because leadership requires forward thinking beyond task management.
- Organisations frequently underinvest in leadership development, causing capability gaps and stalled progress.
- Practical frameworks and mentorship are essential for developing leadership skills effectively.
- Peer learning communities and psychological safety help leaders overcome challenges and avoid burnout.
- Regularly reviewing leadership development outcomes ensures training investments translate into real change and results.
Promoting your top doer to manager can backfire, undermining team results and leadership capability. In this episode of The High Performance Leader, Jimmy Burroughes and guest Paul Teasdale explore the crucial differences between management and leadership, and why technical expertise does not always translate into effective leadership. Gain practical strategies to develop leadership skills and create a culture where managers thrive rather than struggle.
What you will learn
- Understand the pitfalls when promoting high performing doers to management roles
- Identify the critical differences between leadership and management for team success
- Apply practical frameworks to develop your own leadership capability
- Leverage peer learning and psychological safety to overcome leadership challenges
- Recognise the importance of investing in leadership development for long term results
This episode features Paul Teasdale, a leadership expert and consultant, sharing his insights on building sustainable leadership in organisations.
Episode highlights
- (0:00) Intro
- (3:25) The struggle with managers and the distinction between management and leadership
- (7:45) Challenges in leadership development within organisations
- (11:10) The U shaped development curve and its impact on leadership, contextualising tools and frameworks for effective application
- (16:44) Importance of practical frameworks and mentorship in leadership development
- (19:30) The power of peer learning communities and psychological safety in overcoming leadership challenges
- (22:41) Understanding the cognitive energy that leads to potential burnout
- (26:42) Overcoming obstacles to leadership development, funding, and prioritisation dilemma
- (29:55) Underinvestment in leadership training, solutions, and future directions
- (35:27) Outro
Start this week
Turn this episode into action today
The Quick-Win Pack is five five-minute fixes for the overloaded leader, each built on a framework I use with paying clients. Every fix runs live on the page and hands you a finished, ready-to-use plan in minutes, with no AI account of your own needed. Just $19, and included free with Amplify and the Six Week Reset.
Get the Quick-Win PackQuestions managers ask about this episode
Why do good managers fail when they get promoted?
Good managers often fail after promotion because leadership requires looking ahead and supporting long-term goals, not just managing tasks effectively in the moment. Without developing these forward-thinking skills, managers struggle to meet the demands of leadership roles.
How can organisations improve leadership capability?
Organisations can improve leadership capability by investing in practical frameworks, providing mentorship, and creating peer learning communities that offer psychological safety and support continuous growth.
What role does peer learning play in leadership development?
Peer learning communities help leaders share experiences, learn from each other, and build psychological safety, which is crucial for overcoming challenges and reducing the risk of burnout in leadership roles.
How can I measure if leadership training is effective?
To measure leadership training effectiveness, revisit the managers' bosses after training to ask what has changed, tracking improvements in decision-making and leadership behaviours against specific outcomes.